Since Chad was wearing his own suit it didn't seem fair to ask his groomsmen to rent matching black suits, so we asked them to just wear a black suit they already had (or rent one if they didn't). In the end, a black suit is a black suit, and if there were any differences between them we sure didn't notice.
It was a nice way for the guys to save money on a rental and even though Chad didn't save he at least put money towards something he has already worn again and again (I am actually quite jealous that my dress is only suitable for wedding day wear.)
Still worried about tying the guys look together - we gifted them these matching Vineyard Vines ties - done!
Chad's other accessories: a tie that matched the bridesmaids and yellow cufflinks.